posted 06/19/08 08:25 AM

How desperate is Capitol Hill for Mexican food?

Don't do a lot of restaurant reviews here. First, reviews are ripe for overwritten ridiculousness -- each bit of poached muskrat was a mouthful of fantasy. I thought it would be more salty. Second, reviews, especially bad reviews are really hard to write.

So, let me off the hook easy here. Just take my word for it. Don't waste a meal on 15th Ave's entrant in the bland Mexican restaurant hall of fame -- Jalisco. We have tried it out of curiosity. We have tried it out of (relative) thrift. We have tried it out of sympathy. We won't make the mistake again.

The meat was watery, bland. The molten sea of beans and rice was monotony on a plate. The tortillas were soggy. The highlight was the unremarkable margarita and the salsa. Yum on the salsa. Nice work.

Hate to hate on a local business but in this case, it's fair. Some may say just set your expectations knee-high. Better, we think, to head over to El Gallito or to the Broadway outpost of local super chain Tacos Guaymas if you want to stay on the Hill. Taco Gringos if you are loaded past midnight.

Tags: restaurants
Add Your Comment(30)

CommentsRSS Feed
mexi-food
Anyone else here REALLY miss the mexican place above Hana Sushi? God,they had the best Chimichangas...
Comment by Graham
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
RE: mexi-food
YES. Taqueria Express was my favorite Capitol Hill restaurant for years and years. I was so shocked and sad when they closed.
Comment by poppy
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
Don't forget La Puerta
Above the QFC - this spot was a lot more fun before the Broadway Market converted. But you can sit outside, weather willing, and the service and food are good.
Comment by Bart Reynolds
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
I heart Jalisco
I live near Tacos Guaymas on Broadway, but I still walk all the way to Jalisco when I want some good Mexican food. I love it there.
Comment by SeattleBrad
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
RE: I heart Jalisco
What do you order, Brad? Beer and chips, I'd recommend.
Comment by jseattle
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
Don't forget the north Broadway Taco Triangle
Galarias for more interesting recipes and fishbowl margaritas, La Cocina & Cantina for torso-sized burritos and the mysterious Mexican buffet, and the relatively new El Tajin next to Siam. I ate at El Tajin with some friends the day after it opened and reviews were mixed. I have to check it out again sometime though, you can't fairly judge a place on their second day of business.
Comment by Adam
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
Jalisco is OK
I don't hate it. I've had their carne asada and their enchiladas. While they weren't the best I've had -- and I'm tough to please on Mexican having lived in both California and Texas -- I'd go there in a pinch.

But I definitely agree that 15th needs a better Mexican spot. Or at least another one.
Comment by pffft
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
RE: Jalisco is OK
No, you missed my point. Jalisco is NOT OK. Read more carefully, please, pffft.
Comment by jseattle
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
I'm sorry, I didn't realize you were speaking for me
I got your point. I just made a slightly different one. :)
Comment by pffft
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
You must leave the Hill for Mexican
The best Mexican I've had in Seattle--*by far*--is in that bus on Rainier S (what is that, like Columbia City?).

Tacos El Asadero.
(Sorry for the old link, but they have good photos, and the address.)

If anything is worth leaving Capitol Hill for, it's their carnitas.
Comment by yancy
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
Jaliscos
I LOVE JALISCOS. Are we eating the same food? Yummm, I want some right now
Comment by Erin Boniface
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
El Gallito
My wife, daughter, and I have been newly converted to El Gallito. We put off going there for the longest time. Its not the greatest Mexican ever and sometimes the service is slow, but its been really solid food wise and has become a monthly staple for us.
Comment by matthew
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
One word in favor of Jalisco
Toddlers!
Comment by Andrew Taylor
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
Hey, Jalisco's has at least one good dish.
I dunno, I rather like Jalisco's enchiladas. They remind me of the sort of stuff I used to get in Colorado.

I can't really speak to their other stuff since... well... I always get their enchiladas. :)

El Gallito's good too. I like their chimichangas, and their guacamole is for the win.
Comment by Bjorn
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
I dont understand
Don't you white pastey folk have a token Mexican buddy who you are friends with so you get invited to his parents place for authentic Mexican food? or do you just have white friends only? This is the only way to get real Mexican food!!!
Comment by JB
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
El Tajin doesn't wash the vegies
I went to El Tajin once, and all of the tomatoes still had QFC style produce stickers on them. I gagged, I refused to eat more, and I didn't get a discount.

Avoid El skanky El Tajin!
Comment by JS
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
Awwww yeah
Melina's Taco Shop in Queen Anne. Do not test.
Comment by Mike
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
Gallito?
El Gallito? Are you kidding? Have they improved in the last 10 years? That place was so bad we never even gave them a 2nd chance.

It's not Real Mexican, but I'd vote for Cactus as trumping any place mentioned yet... except of course it's not on The Hill.
Comment by Maarten
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
not okay
Jalisco's definitely not okay, unless you're desperate or drunk or both. Even in that case, go to the Canterbury and get some jalapeno poppers or something. :)
Comment by Katelyn
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
you all missed the good ones
I'm from san francisco. So here you go... the best: la carta de oaxaca. Second best: Senor Moose Cafe. Third: Agua Verde. Fourth: El Tajin (sometimes). STAY AWAY from La Cocina, I was so disgusted with their food. They made their enchiladas with flour tortillas. You just don't do that, it's an insult to my people's food.
Comment by a mexican
June 19, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
RE: you all missed the good ones
Yes yes yes! Although, I would add Gordito's to the list. Sorry Hill, you lose this one.
Comment by final answer
June 23, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
RE: you all missed the good ones
Indeed. Good Mexican food is worth the travel.

And I would add the taco truck at the gas station on Rainier -- Taqueria Los Potrillos. You can actually taste all the deliciousness, as opposed to so many other places that dump tons of salt in their stuff.
Comment by hilltop chick
June 29, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
No Quiero Jalisco
I ordered a taco at Jalisco, and it consisted of a crappy store-bought shell (like the bland Taco Bell brand stuff found at QFC), meat, shredded iceberg lettuce, and a big, single chunk of under-ripe tomato. Frankly it was insulting, like they figured it was OK to be lazy and store-bought because the clientele wouldn't recognize good Mexican food anyway. I much prefer Tacos Guaymas. It's the best and most authentic on the Hill, in my opinion.
Comment by Em
June 20, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
El Galito
We live just a few blocks away from El Galito and didn't realize that they were still open. We used to go there more often but the blocks surrounding that restaurant were rather scary after dark in the past few years. A couple of weeks ago, we stopped by for dinner. The food was good, the drinks were strong and the place was happening. We totally recommend it. With Deano's gone, that immediate area should feel even safer.
Comment by ben
June 20, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
There is NO good Mexican food in Seattle.
There is ABSOLUTELY NO good Mexican food in Seattle, PERIOD. Anyone who thinks so has never been to Texas, California, or Mexico.
Comment by No Mex in Seattle
June 23, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
el tajin
Oh, come on...I'm from Texas, have spent lots of time in Mexico and I think the food at El Tajin is the best around here. I've heard mixed reviews about when they first opened but i think they have really improved since then. They make all of their sauces from scratch daily and it's really a family business from what I can see.
Comment by heidi
June 24, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
El Tajin
While I can see why some don't like it, El Tajin is the most authentic of Capitol Hills Mexican haunts.. and the only East Coast mexican I can think of in the city (Vera Cruz region).

To No Mex In Seattle: La Carta de Oaxaca, La Carta de Oaxaca, La Carta de Oaxaca
Comment by Jesse
June 25, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
LA CARTA!!!
LA CARTA IN BALLARD! I have to agree with the mexican who posted above. Worth the trip. trust me.
Comment by Meg
June 25, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
La Carta
I have refused to go to La Carta for many years now due to the yuppie east-siders who always seem to be standing outside while I look for parking to go to the Sunset. However, as Coloradan, I really do miss good mexican food. Dilemma.
Comment by scharrera
July 03, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this
Go to La Carta during the week to avoid eastsiders
it's much more chill on a tuesday, wednesday, or even thursday if you are early enough.

I also like Tenoch on Washington between pioneer square and the ID.
Comment by Finish Tag
August 07, 2008
( 0 votes ) Recommend this