CHS Re:Take | Buy your rubber at City Market

1920 and 2014

1920 and 2014. There’s a good reason that it doesn’t quite match. Keep reading. (Old photo from April 11 1920 Seattle Times)

Back in the 1900s, Pike and Pine were opened up to give unblocked entry from downtown to Capitol Hill. Cars became so popular that the city engineer went looking for another way, finally conceiving a new bent route up the hill from Olive Street’s dead end at Bellevue to the intersection of John and Boylston. After a few years of gestation and fighting it out in courts, construction finished in June 1923. Olive Way was born.

Auto Row, Mowed over by Autos
Of course a whole bunch of buildings stood in the way, including a dozen homes. One of the others we know today as City Market.

The building was completed in 1919 for Ajax Rubber Company of Delaware. They gave it a couple of display windows for retail and a garage door to pull the cars in for new tires. Cantilevered windows provided ventilation as well as plenty of sunlight to work on the cars.

They had no idea

Someone buy this, frame it, and put it on public display. It needs to be famous.

Despite being located several blocks from the car-oriented businesses on auto row, Ajax must have had good sales. The area was still a streetcar neighborhood, served by the Summit Line loop that continued until recently as the Metro 49 bus. But auto traffic grew year by year, and Ajax was on a prime spot on a back door route that dodged Pike and Pine. Olive Street came up and dead-ended right into Ajax’s windows of pneumatic tires. Drivers turned onto Bellevue and then John to get up to Broadway, the new Capitol Hill neighborhood and Volunteer Park.

When the regrade cut through, Ajax closed and the corner of the formerly rectangular building was cut off. Architects like to take advantage of trapezoid buildings by putting the entrance facing out into the intersection. But Ajax’s door was centered between the display windows and it was left there after the cut, creating the very unbalanced arrangement that remains today.

Olive-Way-Before-After

Tweet your current view up Olive Way or submit in comments. (Seattle Times June 24 1923)

President Harding
A month after it opened, Olive Way had its first official visit. President Warren Harding alighted in Seattle briefly as part of a 40-day tour of Alaska and the western states. After looping through downtown his procession headed up Olive Way from 2nd all the way to 15th, and then out to Volunteer Park. At Volunteer Park he and his wife were met by thousands of girls who had been waiting for more than five hours to greet them. His car stopped right in front of where the Seattle Asian Art Museum is today.

“Just opposite the center of the pergola the President’s car halted and Mr. and Mrs. Harding were showered with gifts from the girls of Seattle. Ten little flower girls in their dainty white dresses presented a boutonniere to the President and a blue flower parasol and boa to Mrs. Harding, and at the same time a group of Camp Fire Girls presented their gifts — wood-blocked handkerchiefs for the chief executive and his wife, made by the girls themselves.

“At Seward’s statue the car stopped for a second time. Here the President got out and took part in a brief ceremony for the unveiling of a new bronze tablet at the base of the statue. The ceremony was conducted under the auspices of the China Club. President Harding was very much interested in the statue of the man who made Alaska part of America and walked around to view it from all angles.” (Seattle Times, July 28, 1923)

After just a few hours in Seattle, President Harding boarded his Navy transport and steamed away. Five days later he was dead of a heart attack.

Harding (Wikicommons)

President Harding sez: No Glove, No Love (Library of Congress)

Back in Seattle the city council tried to rename Olive Way to Harding Way in his honor, but the heirs of the pioneer Bell family protested. The road was named after Olive Bell who was just a young girl when she landed at Alki in 1851 with the Denny party. Besieged with letters, the city council rescinded their renaming.

In the early 1930s another effort was made to rename Olive Way — this time to Capitol Way. Once again the pioneer descendants fought off the advances.

The Markets Before City Market
In 1924 insurance salesman Howard McRae decided to get into a different business: groceries. His family’s Eastlake home was not far from the space vacated by Ajax. He opened there as McRae’s Public Market.

Three years later Earl Eba purchased McRae’s and several other stores to add to his Pike Place Market store. This was the beginning of his chain, Eba’s Grocery and Markets. Other nearby stores included 14th and Madison and 23rd and Union. The chain weathered the early years of the Great Depression but in 1931 merged with another chain, Mutual Markets, to form Eba’s Mutual Markets for efficiencies and consolidated assets. Mutual had already closed many stores and the new chain continued shrinking. The store at Bellevue and Olive held tough.

By 1939, Eba’s Mutual was deeply in debt and behind payments on utilities and rent, and so it fell into the possession of its biggest debtor, distributor Pacific Gamble Robinson. With the rest of the chain the Olive Way store was rebranded Tradewell. Tradewell became an incredibly successful chain, rivaling Safeway for the next few decades. In 1945 the store in the old Ajax building closed in favor of a building at Summit and Olive Way.

Did you shop here before City Market opened? Drop a note in comments or Tweet us up and tell us what happened next.

Rebirth of Re:Take
I’m back for another run of neighborhood history and rephotography. If you missed it, here’s an overview of the first year I did 2011-2012. And the two after it: Mt. Zion and WW1 terrorism.

Since then I wrote my first book. Also had some cameos in Hilloween photos. Recently I’m kind of obsessed with Tradewell over on my website which led to this and a few others to come.

Subscribe and support CHS Contributors -- $1/$5/$10 per month

14 thoughts on “CHS Re:Take | Buy your rubber at City Market

  1. Thank you! I LOVE these and I’m glad more articles are in my future. I, too, was unaware that Olive was named after anyone and I didn’t realize Olive had gone through the same Seattle Process to build as we enjoy today.

    (One minor thing – I think you were referring to the Route 47 – rather than 49 – in the sentence about the Summit Line loop.)

    I’ll definitely check out your book!

    • You’re right! I’ll fix that today. It’s crazy that while I was first writing about the Summit line in 2012 it changed from 14 to 47, and now it’s gone.

      Olive and Virginia were the two Bell girls :)

      Thanks for the compliments~

  2. Great article! I love learning about our neighborhood and the rationale behind the way things are. Thank you for sharing.

  3. Thanks for the thorough research and fun read! I never suspected the City Market building being that old, and steeped in that much history. The exterior seems unassuming, and void of the character and detail I often stereotype with buildings from that era. Or maybe I’m just always distracted by those funny newspaper-like comic illustrations in the front. Regardless, I’ll observe the City Market with fresh eyes and new appreciation. Thanks again for that! Look forward to reading more — hint, hint ;)

    • lots of buildings in seattle had their original facades covered up or replaced in the 60s and 80s for a variety of reasons. such awful times for architecture. a good example is the shop rite on 15th ave, which used to have big bay windows and lots of detail and now its an easily overlooked, drab building.

  4. Wow those pictures looking up Olive are so great, that apartment building on the right side is still there and looks exactly the same!

  5. Pingback: CHS Re:Take | Thank Quinault for all the fresh, dried and smoked fish | CHS Capitol Hill Seattle

  6. Pingback: CHS Re:Take | Car Wars — The force awakens at Boren and Pine | CHS Capitol Hill Seattle