Born in the wake of Obama’s victory when patriotism was fashionable and in a Pike/Pine neighborhood where the idea of a daytime-focused business was still a major gamble, Linda Derschang’s “cafe and bar” Oddfellows celebrates a decade on Capitol Hill this week with a Tuesday party.
Inappropriately enough, it starts at 8 PM.
“Oddfellows was the first business I owned equally focused on day and night,” Derschang tells CHS. “It needed to look good at nine in the morning, one in the afternoon, and six at night.”
Oddfellows debuted this week in 2008 in the historic Odd Fellows building at 10th and E Pine and has endured in a changing neighborhood while, yes, looking good around the clock with its big hall-style windows, brick walls, and fellowship lodge neon out front.
Its survival and thriving position as the venerable Capitol Hill High School and Pike/Pine 98122 cafeteria is a testament to Derschang’s style, the neighborhood’s population boom, and community support, Derschang says, through the cafe’s rocky and roll-y start.
In the beginning, even smooshing the “cafe and bar” element together — a mix now common across the Hill — was a neighborhood leap of faith.
Derschang, once known as a queen of Seattle nightlife, would have originally preferred that Oddfellows just be a daytime operation. But she worried the business wouldn’t survive the empty noon-lit streets of Pike and Pine circa 2008. “I wanted an all day, all night cafe because I was afraid we wouldn’t have enough neighborhood business during the day,” Derschang said. “There was barely any people walking down 10th.”
That was far from the biggest challenge Oddfellows faced. When it opened, Oddfellows was hyped as a joint venture from Linda, queen of the bar scene, and Ericka Burke, the up and comer behind North Capitol Hill daytime success, the Volunteer Park Cafe.
The resulting combination was a round-the-clock train wreck.
“Our first year was tough,” Derschang said. “Three months in, Ericka Burke says ‘I need to go back to the Volunteer Park Cafe and check on things’ — and she never came back.”
“Oh my god. She’s not coming back!” Derschang said, recounting the panic. “My kitchen is a disaster!”
But while she says Burke ghosted, Derschang dug in and muscled up, leaning on friends and relationships built up during years in the industry to hold Oddfellows together.
She is still bitter about Burke’s disappearing act — “It was a pretty unbelievable thing to do. Irresponsible and unkind.” — who has gone on to keep the VPC afloat but also run into more trouble in Pike/Pine food and drink after her high profile Chop Shop restaurant financially imploded in 2016 leaving the key commercial space in the middle of Liz Dunn’s Chophouse Row development empty. The debris from that blow-up finally cooled in October when a lawsuit from a group of former employees who say Burke owed them unpaid wages was settled.
With a little bit of help from her lawyer, Derschang said her partnership with Burke was unwound.
More help would come just down the street. In 2010, the Elliott Bay Book Company moved onto Capitol Hill after decades in Pioneer Square. Developer Hunters Capital transformed a 10th Ave auto row warehouse into a new home for what instantly became the largest independent retailer on Capitol Hill. Derschang said the project also was the catalyst needed to boost Oddfellows’s daytime business.
“All of a sudden, you started seeing other businesses geared toward daytime,” she said. “That really was the game changer.”
The cafe and bar’s revenues jumped 35%, Derschang said.
Now Oddfellows is ready to celebrate 10 years of day and night business.
The milestone is also a marker for the neighborhood. Before it was redeveloped and repopulated with retail, food, and drink, the Odd Fellows Hall was run down and ruled by artists. Derschang acknowledges the role her Oddfellows played in changing the building — the cafe literally replaced an acting studio — but hopes that her restaurant’s building represents a healthy version of Pike/Pine’s overhaul.
“People were unhappy that some of the arts organizations were going to have to leave — for good reason,” she says. “The developer could have rented to Starbucks. And Century was able to stay.”
The Century Ballroom marked its long tenure in the building with an announcement of a new 10-year lease in 2017. CHS looked at the Odd Fellows building’s arts tenants including Velocity Dance, Freehold Theatre, Reel Grrls, Annex Theatre, and the Seattle Mime Theatre and the shifts that pushed them out, here.
In 2018 Pike/Pine, displacement concern is likely mostly centered on your favorite bars and restaurants. The arts venues in the Pike/Pine core are fewer and farther in between. The Odd Fellows building changed hands in 2017, purchased by a Las Vegas developer. Yes, luxury eyewear provider Anne and Valentin has plans a space in the building. But the new landlord is happy to keep Oddfellows in the space. Derschang said she just signed a new 10-year lease.
“I want it to carry on as it is now,” she says. “A neighborhood institution. The neighborhood cafeteria. The most Instagrammed restaurant in Seattle,” she laughs. “I want it to carry on.”
Tuesday night, Oddfellows is inviting friends and fans to celebrate the 10th anniversary with Sparkling Rosé Jell-O Shots and Oddfellow’s House Punch as well as signature Oddfellow’s Cocktails in a tin cup in honor of the joint’s “tin anniversary” for 5 bucks. There will be complimentary birthday cake and a bubbly toast. There will be DJs.
For Derschang, there will also be gratitude.
“Not every restaurant gets to have this, the support of the community. People keep rooting for us. People in the neighborhood just kept hoping we would get better,” she said.
“They really believed in the business. That’s what allowed us to get through the hard times.”
And, yes, true to its roots and forever faithful to the morning and lunchtime patrons, Tuesday’s Oddfellows celebration will have a gift for the first 100 daytime customers. Enjoy your “anniversary totes” — and your breakfast.
BECOME A 'PAY WHAT YOU CAN' CHS SUBSCRIBER TODAY: Support local journalism dedicated to your neighborhood. SUBSCRIBE HERE. Join to become a subscriber at $1/$5/$10 a month to help CHS provide community news with NO PAYWALL. You can also sign up for a one-time annual payment.