
CHS broke the news earlier this month that the Seattle City Council was starting the process to decide the future of the controversial program that placed state-of-the-art surveillance cameras inside Cal Anderson Park. After last week’s Council parks committee meeting, we now know that Capitol Hill is about to get the public meetings to discuss the cameras that it never got the first time around when the cameras were installed in 2008.
According to a report issued by the city auditor’s office presented at last Thursday meeting (and available here on CHS), after a $144,000 outlay for hardware and installation and two years of use, city staff were “unable to determine the cameras’ statistical effect on crime with current City crime data” and reported that the cameras had not yet aided the police in crime detection or investigation. Chair of the Parks Committee, Council member Sally Bagshaw was less than pleased with the findings. “I’m troubled by a couple of things. First of all, we’re two months late [hearing the report], so there are cameras that cost $144K to put in the park and we’re not using them…that doesn’t shine too well on us.” After questioning how the city could be using the cameras for this long a period and still not know if they’re making the park safer, she asked the committee “Are we wasting money and are we imposing ourselves in a nanny state effort on people on Capitol Hill?”
According to the SPD, while the cameras continue to operate, the department is not currently utilizing the technology pending the decision by the Council whether to continue the program. SPD says there have only been five requests for live monitoring since the cameras were installed in 2008 and not all of those could be filled. There were six requests for reviews of footage as part of criminal investigations. SPD says that none of the evidence provided by the cameras was useful in the investigations.
After some back and forth between Council members (especially Bagshaw and Tom Rasmussen) doubting the efficacy of the cameras and representatives of the Seattle Police Department defending their effectiveness, Bagshaw proposed that one or two public meetings be held on Capitol Hill concerning the Cal Anderson Park cameras to ensure that the City Council heard from those most affected by the cameras before they made their decision. CHS will keep you updated as to the date and time of these meetings as they are announced. In the meantime, public comment can be addressed to Councilmember Bagshaw at sally.bagshaw(at)seattle.gov.
One interesting exchange from the meeting involved East Precinct Commander Jim Dermody disagreeing with Rasmussen’s assertion that the cameras are not useful. Dermody said he’d like to see the cameras reactivated and cited a recent incident in the park — “a potential felony” — that he would have liked to have used a review of the camera footage to investigate.
Note: Props to Phil Mocek for giving public comment at a morning weekday committee meeting and representing the neighborhood!
Click here for video of the March 18th meeting of the Parks and Seattle Center Committee, agenda item Clerk File 310465, Report of the City Auditor on Cal Anderson Park Surveillance Camera Pilot Program Evaluation.





















