Post navigation

Prev: (06/17/24) | Next: (06/17/24)

Density, powerlines, and development: Here is why it still goes dark on North Capitol Hill

(Image: CHS)

Day-long power outages from June-uary winds and rain that hit over 7,000 Seattle City Light customers in northern Capitol Hill earlier this month didn’t have enough of an impact for the city to consider installing underground power lines. The location of Capitol Hill power outages follows a pattern: in areas where multifamily housing development is less prevalent, power lines sit above ground and are left vulnerable to high winds and storms.

“The recent, sustained high wind event caused many outages throughout our service area including Capitol Hill,” Jenn Strang, media relations manager of SCL, told CHS.

Power outages are frequently caused by fallen trees, wind and ice. Strang said some instances are easier to fix than others, like the outage at 15th St and E Olive St.

“In the case of Monday’s outage at 15th Street East and East Olive, multiple wire spans and crossarms needed to be replaced and repaired which required different crews to complete the tasks,” Strang said.

Installing power lines underground to lessen the risk of outages in the area isn’t an option without larger scale housing development.

For one, it’s expensive — and the city wants developers to pay for it.

Nicholas Rich, client executive at IMEG—a national engineering and design consulting company— said many owners of newly built apartments want City Light to bury overhead power lines underground.

“If you put those underground you really improve the reliability in that respect locally,” Rich told CHS. “Usually a new developer won’t want to do that because City Light is perfectly happy keeping those overhead lines just the way they are.”

If a developer wants power lines underground, they have to pay for it themselves because City Light won’t, Rich said. An upside of burying power lines is the ability to sell more living units, since they aren’t an eyesore.

“Work to install or underground infrastructure is invasive, destructive, expensive, and typically takes years in planning and execution. In addition to the installation of new electrical equipment, these projects require mandated civil improvements such as new street panels, sidewalks, ramps…which must be carefully coordinated with city departments,” Strang said.

Rich said another compelling reason to bury power lines is city safety code that says power lines cannot be closer than 14 feet to any portion of the building: if power lines are buried, it prevent issues with the code.

The areas where the most recent power outages were centered and many of the most serious service disruptions have occurred in recent years represent some of the city’s least-developed blocks dominated by single family-style homes and some of the wealthiest neighborhoods in Seattle.

The city’s latest growth plan, meanwhile, seems unlikely to change that with a proposal that would allow small multifamily development while mostly preserving the status quo in the city’s less-dense areas like North Capitol Hill, and near Volunteer Park and Stevens Elementary.

In Capitol Hill’s densest neighborhood’s the grid is mostly underground including heavy utility work in the city in areas like E Union.

Fifteen years ago in 2009, CHS reported on the start of the city’s most recent push to improve utilities in the quickly growing core of Capitol Hill with a $2 million project planned to move more of the Hill’s wiring underground, make the system better able to deliver service even when there are incidents when wiring is damaged and electricity needs to be re-routed, and make other improvements to strengthen reliability.

One of the most significant components of the upgrade was replacements of pockets of old wiring that were still serving Capitol Hill customers. The standard for electrical wire is 26,000 volt capacity. In 2009, parts of the Hill were still served by 4,000 volt wiring. We’d bet there are still a few strands of the old stuff out there in service.

City Light also installed areas of bigger poles and thicker lines to meet the electricity requirements for Capitol Hill Station. And in 2013, City Light finished replacing an overhead mainline near Capitol Hill in order to serve the hospitals and Seattle University.

Despite Capitol Hill’s development boom, City Light officials told CHS a decade ago the biggest challenge isn’t in meeting the demand for power but instead the complicated scheduling and manpower required to move electrical poles and lines to make way for new construction and provide hook-ups when construction crews need it. The boom has helped speed up the process of moving more lines underground as crews can take advantage of disconnecting components during new construction.

City Light moving a new transformer into place last year at the East Pine Substation (Image: Seattle City Light)

Today, Strang said SCL is in the process of developing a long-term plan that includes systemwide upgrades to Seattle’s underground infrastructure. Once the plan is approved and has secured resources for implementation, SCL will share timelines and locations with neighborhoods that will be impacted.

Until then, SCL is carrying on with upgrades to their East Pine Substation in the Central District, which provides power to the area and a couple of hospitals.  A goal of the project is to provide the lowest cost and most reliable power to SCL customers. The upgrade includes the expansion of two walls closer towards the facility’s property lines for future equipment upgrades, which will also have security improvements.

Strang said those at risk of losing power should keep an emergency bag packed with non-perishable food items, batteries, warm clothing and extra medications.

 

$5 A MONTH TO HELP KEEP CHS PAYWALL-FREE THIS SPRING
🌈🐣🌼🌷🌱🌳🌾🍀🍃🦔🐇🐝🐑🌞🌻 

Subscribe to CHS to help us hire writers and photographers to cover the neighborhood. CHS is a pay what you can community news site with no required sign-in or paywall. To stay that way, we need you.

Become a subscriber to help us cover the neighborhood for $5 a month -- or choose your level of support 👍 

 
Subscribe and support CHS Contributors -- $1/$5/$10 per month

18 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Hillery
Hillery
11 months ago

This is a red herring to the fact that even if the equipment is above ground, mis-managed SCL has a lot of aging infrastructure that makes it worse than it should be. I’ve lived in areas with severe weather and had to be really really bad to do what happens all the time here when it’s just a zephyr of a sea breeze in June.

Capitol Hill Neighbor
Capitol Hill Neighbor
11 months ago

I remember reading that post back in 2009. It doesn’t seem that long ago, but a lot has happened in the neighborhood. Thank you to Justin and all of the CHS contributors over the years for keeping us up to date all of this time!

DD15
DD15
11 months ago

“In the case of Monday’s outage at 15th Street East and East Olive, multiple wire spans and crossarms needed to be replaced and repaired which required different crews to complete the tasks,” Strang said.

There is no 15th Street East in Seattle. 15th Ave East exists, but it doesn’t intersect with East Olive [Way or Street]. 15th Ave (no
directional) intersects with East Olive Street. This intersection is also not close to where the major outage was (and where frequent outages occur) in northern Capitol Hill. So, it’s difficult to understand why this supposedly difficult repair kept people without power for so long.

ConfusedGay
ConfusedGay
11 months ago
Reply to  DD15

It was hard to repair because they couldn’t find it.

d4l3d
d4l3d
11 months ago

I have thought it telling and jarring to see the existing unimproved overheads next to the “futureproof” design statement Denny Substation as emblematic.

I Got The Power and Want to Share
I Got The Power and Want to Share
11 months ago

The power outages in Seattle are outdated and preventable nonsense.

I moved from Seattle to Tumwater a few years ago. I pay less to Puget Sound Energy for the same amount of power usage I got from Seattle City Light. I have true 24/7 connectivity here because power lines are buried in the industrial and urban areas. The only outage I’ve had in 3 years was when some nutjobs cut the power at a regional substation. That mess was fixed faster by PSE than a downed neighborhood tree in Seattle would be fixed by SCL.

My local friends laugh at my Go Bags full of fruit leathers and flashlights that I still have stashed in my home after a lifetime of shitty access to Seattle electric power. The joking skepticism they feel must be like the disbelief I had in an urban power grid without weekly, sometimes daily, outages.

It doesn’t take a bunch of billionaires or brainiacs to fix Seattle’s many, frequent power outages if places like little old Tumwater can do it right.

E15 resitdent
E15 resitdent
11 months ago

Why are you on this page then?

Got The Power and Want to Share
Got The Power and Want to Share
11 months ago
Reply to  E15 resitdent

Same reasons everyone is here – to see when the power is gonna be back on and passionately hate Portland based donut chains.

Meg
Meg
11 months ago

The small size of a place like Tumwater almost certainly makes it easier for underground power construction to be coordinated, not harder. Dense populations have different needs & present challenges that aren’t going to exist in a city that has, quite literally, less than 5% the population size of Seattle.

Neighbor
Neighbor
11 months ago

There has been a lot of development around 23rd and E. Union, but the city just doubled down on above-ground and added new poles in the adjacent neighborhood. While leaving the old poles in place and connected. Curious where there are examples of buried lines?

I Got The Power and Want to Share
I Got The Power and Want to Share
11 months ago
Reply to  Neighbor

Seattle Center public grounds and the little square of land in it that the privately owned Space Needle sits on (the Needle also has its own emergency generators) are an example of buried power lines in Seattle.

I worked and lived on Denny Way and I lost power there a lot. So I remember a lot of spicy phone calls to SCL where I asked WTF the Space Needle a few blocks away had power but I didn’t. Never got a definitive answer why I lost my power but I guess I learned why the Space Needle had theirs.

I have also lived in a parts of Magnolia and the U District where the lines had always been buried.

Charles
Charles
11 months ago
Reply to  Neighbor

The CD itself has a prime example of buried power lines in the rectangle formed from Yesler Way to Cherry and MLK to 32nd.

Nandor
Nandor
11 months ago

Being buried doesn’t do much… I live down the street from the substation. Let me tell you- it’s an interesting thing when there’s a neighborhood rousing boom in the middle of the night and you come out to find all of your neighbors staring at the smoke pouring out of all the vault covers and manholes. That was a couple of years ago, and I’m pretty sure whatever failed that night is still broken.

Steve
Steve
11 months ago

Burying existing power lines that aren’t part of a new development is extremely pricey, somewhere north of a million dollars per mile. That’s a lot of extra money the city would have to come up with, meaning from you and me. Some years back both Florida and North Carolina had initiatives on the ballot to require power lines to be buried, but they failed when folks found out the utilities would likely have to raise rates by 80 to 100%.

Hillery
Hillery
11 months ago
Reply to  Steve

Yeah and if the city is wanting developers to pay for it well that’s going to get hidden in the housing costs of these mega corp buildings over time for sure.

dang
dang
11 months ago
Reply to  Steve

*expensive whether existing or part of a new development. The going rate to underground power lines for a new apartment building is north of $1000 per foot. And oftentimes the length to be put underground is increased because risers (the transition from underground to overhead) can’t happen on a corner pole or a pole with pole mounted transformers (unless those are put in a new vault that is put underground and the buildings serviced are back fed) and so on. It’s a complex undertaking that is heavily regulated due to the very real safety issues. That it is done in a piece meal fashion just adds to the complexity and costs.

Guesty
Guesty
11 months ago
Reply to  Steve

Phht, that’s less expensive than bike lanes AND way more useful for everyone…

Matt
Matt
11 months ago

We have become overly reliant on electricity. The majority of “demand” is for completely unnecessary needs that society would benefit without access to every once and a while. I would love to see an emphasis on emergency services to those in immediate need, and then a system and community that can manage offline for a bit…