Zohran Mamdani’s political surge in New York City, of course, has a grocery store element.
Soaring prices, faded services, and eroded humanity are an industry-wide trend that is hitting hardest in America’s largest, busiest, most expensive cities.
With this month’s nearly overnight closure of the Broadway Whole Foods only the latest major grocery corporation cutback in the city, don’t look to Seattle leadership to champion city-run grocery stores — yet.
“I’m not looking to legislate anything,” District 3 representative Joy Hollingsworth told CHS about her comments following the rapid shutdown of the Broadway at Madison Whole Foods two weeks ago.
The Broadway closure came as the Amazon-run company said “performance and growth potential” were behind the decision. CHS reported that a massive $173 million real estate deal and a Whole Foods-friendly lease clause were also in play.
The seven-year-old, two-level, 40,000-square-foot grocery at the base of The Danforth luxury apartment building now sits empty, joining the shuttered former Amazon Fresh only a few blocks away on E Pike on Capitol Hill’s sad roster of major empty commercial spaces.
Hollingsworth said she is concerned about the loss.
“Losing a grocery store and a critical food access point is a real blow to our community,” the first-term representative for Capitol Hill and the Central District said on social media following CHS’s report on the Whole Foods shutdown. “We know the remaining three stores on Broadway are also facing challenges. I’ve constantly been elevating these concerns as our grocery stores are not just businesses, they’re lifelines.”
The three groceries Hollingsworth references include two remaining QFCs on Broadway and the 2022-born M2M “urban convenience” concept store from Asian supermarket giant H Mart.
A third QFC is closed and lined up for demolition to make way for a new six-story mixed-use development on 15th Ave E that is unlikely to include a return of a major grocer. The 15th at John Safeway, meanwhile, will eventually be demolished, too, as the company’s property at the corner is redeveloped as two new five-story buildings including a new grocery, around 330 market rate apartment units, some new, smaller retail spaces, and an underground parking lot for more than 300 cars. A Safeway also serves the area at 22nd and Madison.
There are also worries in the Central District where one of three remaining Amazon Fresh-brand supermarkets in the city now holds down the corner where major redevelopment replaced the neighborhood’s Red Apple grocery store. The 2021-opened 23rd and Jackson Amazon Fresh is now one of the last of its kind after the company’s most recent shutdown cut more than 100 jobs in Federal Way.
Grocery delivery revenue, meanwhile, has continued to grow, raising the bar for in-store performance. While Whole Foods is referring shoppers to its other area stores, it is also reminding that customers “can shop Amazon.com/grocery for a broad selection of 3 million grocery and household essentials.”
Hollingsworth, who has been a champion of food security and proponent of Black ownership of farmlands and food-focused businesses, says the grocery issue is a priority in her office and that she is working with city departments and King County to address issues and “explore every avenue to protect and support these essential businesses for our residents.”
For now, it seems unlikely Hollingsworth is looking toward New York for guidance. Among Democratic mayoral primary winner Zohran Mamdani’s proposals for lowering the cost of living in NYC is a promise to cut subsidies to massive grocery chains and redirect the funding to create a network of city-owned grocery stores that will sell at wholesale prices and “operate without a profit motive.”
In Seattle, the grocery chains are currently exempt from the city’s payroll tax on its largest employers.
Grocery access is also a core element of the city’s “Food Action Plan” that Hollingsworth is working to shape and implement though most of the city’s $30 million a year program is already dedicated to programs like Fresh Bucks which provides $40 stipends to income-qualifying residents to spend on fresh produce from participating retailers as well as the framework for the city’s food programs and community P-Patch gardens.
Hollingworth tells CHS she is not currently pursuing any legislation to address the issues, instead focusing on working out better coordination with departments like Public Health and public service departments.
“I don’t have an answer but trying to establish better forms of communication for our grocery stores and city/county departments,” Hollingsworth said.
$5 A MONTH TO HELP KEEP CHS PAYWALL-FREE
🌈🐣🌼🌷🌱🌳🌾🍀🍃🦔🐇🐝🐑🌞🌻
Subscribe to CHS to help us hire writers and photographers to cover the neighborhood. CHS is a pay what you can community news site with no required sign-in or paywall. To stay that way, we need you.
Become a subscriber to help us cover the neighborhood for $5 a month -- or choose your level of support 👍
Hopefully another market comes into that space but not sure what even would. Target (maybe before but not these days), PCC, Metro Market or it will sit vacant for years.
It’s not like that area is short of grocery stores is it? There’s a QFC 2 blocks away from where the Whole Foods was and the Co-op and Trader Joes just along Maddison – and that ignores the Safeway (that admittedly is closing) and another QFC not much further away.
Shouldn’t this all have been foreseeable with a business plan and tax information?
City run grocery stores — customer service expertise from the DMV, produce management by the Department of Revenue. Can’t wait.
The DMV runs fine here thank you very much, and a city run grocery store would just undercut private prices due and pass the savings of being a gov institution onto the customers. That sounds awesome and you’re silly not to support it, unless you own a grocery chain?? Didn’t think so lol. Nice of you to say hello from the land of political insults circa 1985 though
Neither of those are City departments, and in Washington, it’s the Department of Licensing, not the DMV.
Personal anecdotes are not scientific data, but is everyone really having these godawful experiences at the DMV? I upgraded to the Real ID in under ten minutes, and the lady helping me couldn’t have been nicer. No idea if city-run grocery stores would prove feasible, but the oppo research will have to do better than a hackneyed “what’s the deal with airline food?” cliché.
“I’m not looking to legislate anything” could be council member Hollingsworth’s calling card
PLEASE YES
Can’t wait to experience the joys of this…
(Even Safeway, at its suckiest sounds better)
Surely after rent control we can socialize the groceries. It’s even more of a human right to have affordable food ?!
Not under Hollingsworth unfortunately…
We will need free bread and circuses
Is there any organization that is advocating for municipal grocery store?
Or maybe the city should work to identify and correct the underlying issues that are driving the closure of grocery stores in the area?
Shoplifting, high taxes, utilities and wages, some of the highest fuel prices in the country (yes, that’s how groceries get to the store), and a government with an anti-business attitude… well, this is what you get. If government runs grocery stores, how would the cost dynamics be any different? Grocery stores operate on a 1% to 2% net margin. They procure in large volumes in order to get the lowest prices available. A city cannot purchase in volumes anything close to this, let alone operate the supply chain at similar costs. You would be getting Red Apple quality at bodega prices
Hollingsworth is not doing anything to address the problems in Capitol Hill. It’s getting worse with every passing day. I’m not sure how any business can survive here and she is a businesswoman? They are struggling because of the criminal activities here and I’m sure that was one of the reasons why Whole Foods left. Enough of socialistic propaganda. We need a law and order here for the start.