A permanent memorial to the 2020 protests, Capitol Hill’s Black Lives Matter street mural gets fresh coat of paint

The colors of the Black Lives Matter mural that mark the site of the 2020 CHOP protests on Capitol Hill are brighter this morning.

The art, now maintained as a permanent element of the E Pine streetscape by the Seattle Department of Transportation, is getting a round of maintenance and touch-ups this weekend with some of the original artists participating in the work.

SDOT said it expects the mural will require periodic refreshes over the years. Continue reading

Inquest: Seattle Police shooting of Charleena Lyles justified

A poster hung during the CHOP protests on Capitol Hill

Two Seattle police officers were justified in fatally shooting Charleena Lyles, an inquest jury found Wednesday.

The decision ended a painful legal process examining the decisions by the two Seattle police officers who shot and killed the pregnant, Black mother inside her apartment in the summer of 2017. Lyles was carrying a knife and suffering a mental crisis when the shooting occured. Continue reading

Seattle settles one CHOP lawsuit with wrongful death deal over teen gunned down on edge of protest zone

 

$5 A MONTH TO HELP KEEP CHS PAYWALL-FREE
🌈🐣🌼🌷🌱🌳🌾🍀🍃🦔🐇🐝🐑🌞🌻 

Subscribe to CHS to help us hire writers and photographers to cover the neighborhood. CHS is a pay what you can community news site with no required sign-in or paywall. To stay that way, we need you.

Become a subscriber to help us cover the neighborhood for $5 a month -- or choose your level of support 👍 

 
 

A memorial left near where Anderson died in June 2020

The City of Seattle has settled a wrongful death lawsuit in the June 2020 shooting of 19-year-old Lorenzo Anderson on the edge of CHOP.

The settlement hammered out late last year and approved by a judge this spring shuts down proceedings on a claim brought in King County Superior Court seeking billions brought by Anderson’s father. A federal case brought by Anderson’s mother was dismissed late last year but is being appealed.

The legal process for the 19-year-old’s alleged murderer continues. Prosecutors say 18-year-old Marcel Long shot and killed the teen at 10th and Pine in a June 2020 fracas after what witnesses said was a night of gambling and fireworks on the edge of the CHOP protest camp. Long, 18 at the time of the shooting, was arrested a year later in Des Moines, Washington by a U.S. Marshals led task force and is currently awaiting trial. Continue reading

South Seattle Emerald report on Chief Best text messages could cloud city’s defense against ‘deliberate indifference’ CHOP lawsuit

The South Seattle Emerald has posted a new report based on text log transcripts from messages between former SPD Chief Carmen Best and Assistant Police Chief Lesley Cordner from June 2020

Text messages reveal both former Chief Carmen Best and Mayor Jenny Durkan and her office may have been more involved in the decision to abandon Capitol Hill’s East Precinct than either has previously disclosed, according to new reporting from the South Seattle Emerald.

The revelations could further jeopardize the city’s chances of defending itself in an ongoing federal lawsuit accusing City Hall of “deliberate indifference” in allowing the CHOP occupied protest area to form and cutting off the area from city services for weeks in the summer of 2020 amid concerns about dangerous conditions around the camp and protest.

The new revelations surrounding text messages between the former police chief and her assistant chief in the days leading up to the June 2020 formation of the Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone were reported by the Emerald’s Carolyn Bick last week:

According to texts between Best and Assistant Police Chief Lesley Cordner, it appears that Best was in contact with former Mayor Jenny Durkan about the Seattle Police Department (SPD) removing items from the East Precinct and that she was aware, on the morning of June 8, 2020, of a plan to remove firearms, ammunition, and evidence from the building by 5 p.m. that day.

Continue reading

Judge denies class action in CHOP ‘deliberate indifference’ lawsuit against city

SDOT officials were on hand as the city placed barriers around the CHOP protest zone in June 2020 (Image: @mmitgang)

A legal bid that could have added hundreds of Capitol Hill residents and businesses to the federal lawsuit against the City of Seattle over “deliberate indifference” in its response to the CHOP occupied protest zone in the summer of 2020 has been denied.

Meanwhile, a handful of Pike/Pine and 12th Ave small businesses that had been part of the suit have dropped out as it continues into its third year of litigation seeking damages from the city over the protest zone.

In a ruling earlier this month, a U.S. District Court judge denied the effort at class certification in the CHOP lawsuit, rejecting arguments from plaintiffs that people living and doing business in a 16-block area near the unrest amid dangerous clashes between campers, demonstrators, and police in the protest zone should be eligible to join the potentially multi-million dollar suit.

Judge Thomas Zilly ruled the lawsuit does not meet the requirements for a class action because of the specific damages to each plaintiff.

“Plaintiffs in this case claim they were subject to diverse harms (violence, vandalism, harassment, blocked streets and sidewalks, excessive noise, and reduced business revenue) caused by the City’s actions, or inaction, in relation to CHOP,” Zilly writes, noting that cases of class action precedent include plaintiffs alleging the same “unlawful harm” like “mass arrest without probable cause,” for example.

Former Mayor Jenny Durkan’s missing text messages from the period continue to loom in the background of the case. Continue reading

‘SPD’s legitimacy and its ability to control crowd movements’ — Latest report on what went wrong in Seattle Police’s response to 2020 Black Lives Matter protests focuses on six days at 11th and Pine

Seattle’s Office of Inspector General for Public Safety has released the second in a series of five painstaking and sometimes frustratingly methodical analyses part of the city’s official review of public safety implications from 2020’s Black Lives Matter and anti-police protests and the Seattle Police Department’s flawed response to the unrest.

The focus of Wave 2: Mostly 11th and Pine.

The takeaways from the 23-member community panel for Wave 2: Massive distrust of SPD and the department’s flawed actions led to the transformation of Black Lives Matter protests into anti-police demonstrations, and tactics including tear gas, blast balls, and fixed barriers blocking streets made an unsafe environment for police, protesters, and residents of the surrounding Capitol Hill neighborhood.

While the Wave 1 report examined the dates of May 29th to June 1st, 2020 when the seeds were planted for weeks of protests including the CHOP occupied protest and came away with findings critical of SPD responses and tactics that contributed to the unrest, the Wave 2 report, below, examines what came next as citywide demonstrations were focused on Capitol Hill and the demonstrations quickly shifted leading to the establishment of CHOP.

“By the start of Wave 2,” the Wave 2 report reads, “what had begun as a broad social movement against systemic racism and police brutality had evolved into a more focused statement from many in the community against SPD’s legitimacy and its ability to control crowd movements.”

 

$5 A MONTH TO HELP KEEP CHS PAYWALL-FREE
🌈🐣🌼🌷🌱🌳🌾🍀🍃🦔🐇🐝🐑🌞🌻 

Subscribe to CHS to help us hire writers and photographers to cover the neighborhood. CHS is a pay what you can community news site with no required sign-in or paywall. To stay that way, we need you.

Become a subscriber to help us cover the neighborhood for $5 a month -- or choose your level of support 👍 

 
 

Continue reading

Black bloc demonstrators sentenced in baseball bat attack on cop and East Precinct fires

 

$5 A MONTH TO HELP KEEP CHS PAYWALL-FREE
🌈🐣🌼🌷🌱🌳🌾🍀🍃🦔🐇🐝🐑🌞🌻 

Subscribe to CHS to help us hire writers and photographers to cover the neighborhood. CHS is a pay what you can community news site with no required sign-in or paywall. To stay that way, we need you.

Become a subscriber to help us cover the neighborhood for $5 a month -- or choose your level of support 👍 

 
 

(Image: King County Prosecuting Attorney)

Sentences were handed down Friday to two defendants charged in arson attacks against the East Precinct and an assault of a police officer with a baseball bat caught on video that became infamous on social media during the anti police protests that followed CHOP’s clearance from Capitol Hill in 2020.

Jacob Greenburg was sentenced Friday to five years in prison. CHS reported here in December on the plea deal reached in which Greenburg’s legal team agreed to the lengthy sentence in exchange for reduced charges against the defendant. Greenburg, a stepson of a former Washington state representative and 19 at the time of the incident, was charged with the September 2020 baseball bat assault on Officer Jose Jimenez along with charges of arson over Molotov cocktail attacks at the East Precinct. Continue reading

‘At what point should people have known?’ — Larger questions about Seattle Police disinformation and ‘chain of command’ during protest response overshadow Proud Boy radio ruse — UPDATE

Former Chief Best at a press conference at CHOP in the summer of 2020 (Image: CHS)

A Seattle City Council committee meeting Tuesday morning included calls for training and policy changes but also opened the door to a wider ranging probe connecting the so-called “improper ruse” of the Proud Boys disinformation effort to the decision to abandon the East Precinct and other operations by the Seattle Police Department during the summer of 2020 in which investigators have identified and sometimes recommended discipline for lower ranking commanders and officers for their parts in the inappropriate and often dangerous actions while citing a lack of documentation and oversight at the department’s highest levels including then Chief Carmen Best and current interim Chief Adrian Diaz.

“People in the high command didn’t know about things,” Councilmember Andrew Lewis said during his questions to Andrew Myerberg, director of the city’s Office of Police Accountability. “At what point should people have known?”

Tuesday’s meeting of the council’s Public Safety and Human Services Committee was the first public hearing following last week’s delayed release of the OPA report on findings that former Assistant Chief Bryan Grenon, as head of the department’s Special Operations Center convened to manage the city’s response to the 2020 protest, signed off on a dangerous disinformation ploy targeting demonstrators as the CHOP protest zone formed on Capitol Hill.

Committee chair Lisa Herbold said her focus was on policies and the use of “ruses” that she said are legal under state law but “need additional oversight and must be documented.”

But the OPA director said, while he shared Herbold’s concerns about policy, he agreed with Lewis that the larger concern about the Proud Boy radio ruse in which officers were approved to broadcast false reports of an armed right wing group headed for Capitol Hill as the protest camp formed wasn’t about the use of a tactic that can be appropriate “in the context of a criminal investigation” but about Seattle Police officers deploying an intentional disinformation campaign. Continue reading

‘Improper ruse’ — Investigation finds Seattle Police officers faked reports about armed Proud Boys headed to CHOP — UPDATE: Harrell statement

The scene outside the East Precinct on June 8th, 2020

The hours after Seattle Police abandoned the East Precinct and the CHOP occupied protest zone was formed on June 8th, 2020 were chaotic — and dangerous.

In the midst of that chaos, SPD leadership including an assistant chief signed off on a deliberate hoax that capitalized on the widespread availability of services broadcasting police radio transmissions to spread rumors of a group of 20 to 30 armed right wing extremists roaming the streets of city and headed to Capitol Hill for a fight.

These findings of the department’s Office of Police Accountability after its year-long investigation into the “inappropriate ruse” comes likely too late to bring punishment to those directly involved. In its findings, the investigation lays the blame for the misinformation disinformation effort with two supervisors including the assistant chief. Both supervisors have since left the department, according to the report.

UPDATE: A researcher working to study disinformation points out that the OPA’s use of the word “misinformation” is incorrect. Misinformation implies the spreading of incorrect reports and observations regardless of intent. Disniformation, on the other hand, implies deliberate acts to mislead as is the case in the findings from this investigation. We have updated our report throughout.

UPDATE x2: Mayor Bruce Harrell has issued a statement on the report saying he plans to meet with Chief Diaz and push for new legislation “to ensure this does not happen again.”

Continue reading

‘The Guardian of Seattle,’ Dan Gregory has hopes for Carnegie Medal — Fernandez trial set for 2022

Dan Gregory

Dan Gregory, the unarmed man shot as he tried to disarm the brother of an East Precinct officer who drove into a Black Lives Matter demonstration crowd at 11th and Pine in the summer of 2020 protests on Capitol Hill, said Wednesday he is being nominated for the Carnegie Medal, an award presented for acts of extraordinary heroism.

Gregory made the announcement Wednesday morning on the air with John Richards on KEXP where Gregory now works as a security guard.

The court case of the shooter in the incident, meanwhile, is now scheduled to begin trial early in the new year. Continue reading