
The future 12th at E Olive St? (Image: Runberg Architecture Group)
The largest development taking shape on Capitol Hill has, perhaps unsurprisingly, also generated the most pushback from neighbors and the biggest challenges for the city’s design review process.
The Mack Real Estate group has plans for an eight-story building at 1710 12th Ave, just north of the affordable 12th Ave Arts development. The land is currently occupied by the former Car Tender auto shop, Bergman’s Lock and Key, and the old Scratch Deli building. The market rate, mixed-use project set to reshape the block started the design review process in late 2019 and returns, now, for the final step still facing stacks of questions and following iterations that have seen at least six different design concepts presented for review.
In its most recent pass in front of the East Design Review Board in November, frustration about the project and concerns about its relationship to the lower heights and smaller scale housing off of 12th bled through. The board split in its opinion that the project could move forward with two of the board members siding with public comment and voting to make the project return for yet another early design guidance session “to consider additional massing alternatives and response to context.” The proposed building related too much to the larger scale of the 12th Ave Arts development and not enough to the small apartment buildings and houses nearby.
“The Board recognized the large volume of public comment with concerns regarding the height, bulk, and scale of this project relative to recent up-zoning changes, the existing context and the adjacent lower intensity zone and agreed that these issues were of critical importance in developing the design of the project,” the report on the most review session for the project reads.
1710 12th Ave
Land Use application to allow an 8-story, 134-unit apartment building with retail. Parking for 83 vehicles proposed. Existing buildings to be demolished. Design Review Early Design Guidance done under 3035745-EG. View Design Proposal (32 MB)
Review Meeting
July 28, 2021 7:00 PM
Review Phase
REC–Recommendation
But there is light at the end of the long process tunnel. Wednesday, the project team enters what could be the final review for the project believing its has found solutions for the problems of scale and relationship to the neighborhood.
“Massing and modulation have been adjusted to reflect/reference this smaller scale and create an appropriate transition,” the design review packet reads. “The preferred scheme does draw inspiration from the neighboring 12th Ave Arts building, but now also incorporates inspiration from the neighborhood to the north, west and east as well.” Continue reading →